Blending the Past and Present
Josh Cain

When Josh Cain purchased his property in 2015, it came with a familiar piece of Ooltewah’s history: Plott’s Repair Shop, an old mechanic’s garage that operated from the 1950s to the late 1990s.
PHOTOS BY CHRIS HENDRIX/CREATIVE REVOLVER
Rather than tear it down, Cain and his family chose to preserve the garage’s history and character while also updating the space to give it new life.
“For many locals, the former repair shop was a beloved part of the community, so preserving its history was important to us,” shares Cain. “While we updated the building and brought it into the present, we were careful to hold onto the details that made it special, including the original hand-painted Champion Spark Plugs sign that still remains on the exterior.”
Today, that old repair shop houses the offices for Cain Development, the groom’s lounge for The Gray Dove, and a comfortable and inviting place for the Cain family to enjoy. For a family known for its businesses, sports legacy, and strong family ties, the garage has become a place where all those interests come together.
“What makes the garage so unique is its versatility,” adds Cain.
“It seamlessly blends business, entertaining, and our personal interests all under one roof. It’s a place where we can work, gather with family and friends, and enjoy our passion for classic cars – all while surrounded by a piece of local history.”
Over the years, Cain and his family have filled the space with pieces that have caught their eye and reflect their interests. Rustic signs, a bar made out of the hood of a car, and vintage motorcycles hung on the wall add to the garage’s rustic atmosphere, while a pool table, flat-screen TV, and retro arcade games offer plenty of entertainment.
“The garage already had a vintage charm of its own, so we embraced it,” says Cain. “The result is a reflection of the things we love most – a mix of nostalgia, character, and, of course, plenty of classic muscle cars.”
From family gatherings to afternoons spent admiring classic cars, Cain and his family have made countless memories in the garage, but some of the most meaningful moments come from sharing the space with the community that remembers what it once was.
“Over the years, people have stopped to take photos, reminisce about the past, and even gift us hand-drawn paintings of the building,” says Cain. “Those moments are a special reminder that this garage is more than just a space – it’s a piece of Ooltewah’s history.”