The Spicy Mami Hoagy Recipe

Handheld Faves

Who doesn’t love a good portable meal? Handheld menu items – from sandwiches to burgers to hot dogs and beyond – are beloved and multipurpose. Whether you’re layering breakfast meats, assembling an on-the-go lunch, or adding some simplicity to a sit-down dinner, handhelds are there to pack a flavorful punch. Here, local restaurants share some of their favorite handheld staples and what makes them special.

Photography by Lanewood Studio

The Spicy Mami

Lil Mama’s Chicago-Style Hoagy

 

Tiffany Pauldon-Banks, Owner of Lil Mama's Chicago-Style Hoagy

 

“I’m not really a huge spicy food person, but I know a lot of people who are, so I wanted to create a hoagy for them! You have your tangy, spicy ingredients like spicy mustard, banana peppers, and jalapeños balanced by the savory, spicy ingredients like the pepper jack cheese and the Cajun mayo. The tomatoes, lettuce, and onions add a nice freshness. The honey-roasted turkey that we put on all our hoagies and our famous oil let you know you’re eating a Lil Mama’s hoagy. All the ingredients work together to accomplish an explosion of flavor.”

– Tiffany Pauldon-Banks, Owner

McCoy homes ad

Ingredients

  • 1 hoagy roll 
  • Lil Mama’s house-made Cajun mayo
  • Spicy mustard
  • 2 slices pepper jack cheese
  • 6 oz. honey-roasted turkey
  • Lettuce, shredded
  • Tomato, sliced
  • Onion, sliced
  • Pickled jalapeños, sliced
  • Banana peppers, sliced
  • Drizzle of Lil Mama’s Famous Oil
  • Crushed red pepper
  • Parmesan 

Directions

Slice open a hoagy roll and gut some of the bread from the inside. Slather opposite sides with Lil Mama’s house-made Cajun mayo and spicy mustard. Add the pepper jack cheese and the honey-roasted turkey. Top with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickled jalapeños, and sliced banana peppers. Finish with a drizzle of Lil Mama’s Famous Oil, crushed red pepper, and Parmesan. 

Village Volkswagen ad

 

The Spicy Mami Hoagy

The Spicy Mami Hoagy

Lil Mama's Chicago-Style Hoagy
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Servings 1 person

Ingredients
  

  • 1 hoagy roll
  • Lil Mama's house-made Cajun mayo
  • Spicy mustard
  • 2 slices pepper jack cheese
  • 6 oz. honey-roasted turkey
  • Lettuce, shredded
  • Tomato, sliced
  • Onion, sliced
  • Pickled jalapeños, sliced
  • Drizzle of Lil Mama's Famous Oil
  • Crushed red pepper
  • Parmesan

Instructions
 

  • Slice open a hoagy roll and gut some of the bread from the inside.
  • Slather opposite sides with Lil Mama’s house-made Cajun mayo and spicy mustard.
  • Add the pepper jack cheese and the honey-roasted turkey.
  • Top with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickled jalapeños, and sliced banana peppers.
  • Finish with a drizzle of Lil Mama’s Famous Oil, crushed red pepper, and Parmesan. 
Keyword Chicago, Hoagy, Sandwich, spicy, Sub, Turkey
McCoy homes ad

You Also Might Like

Readers’ Choice Dining Awards 2021 Winners
Canyon grill food Dining Award Winners

2021 Best Restaurants   Readers voted, and the results are in! Here's a list of all the restaurant that won Read more

Midnight Sky Cocktail Recipe
Midnight Sky Cocktail

Pitcher Perfect For those who love to entertain, having a delicious cocktail recipe is a must. A perfect primer to Read more

Bourbon Spritz Cocktail Recipe
Bourbon Spritz Cocktail form Hennen's

Serving Up Sparkles Every cocktail connoisseur has that one recipe in their arsenal that offers up opulence and has the Read more

Venetian 75 Cocktail Recipe
Venetian 75 cocktail from Company at the Kinley Hotel

Serving Up Sparkles Every cocktail connoisseur has that one recipe in their arsenal that offers up opulence and has the Read more

Caramelized Vidalia Onion Dip Recipe
Caramelized Vidalia Onion Dip from Café 7

Dips That Delight When a social gathering is afoot, dips never fail to rise to the occasion. This swipe- and Read more

Classic Gin Martini Recipe
Classic Gin Martini

Pitcher Perfect For those who love to entertain, having a delicious cocktail recipe is a must. A perfect primer to Read more